Take the 2-minute tour ×
Android Enthusiasts Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for enthusiasts and power users of the Android operating system. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I do have HTC Desire HD and I rooted it but I'm not sure how valuable is the HTC Sense package and if it makes "sense" (funny) to use a 2.2 firmware with HTC Sense or just to go for the plain Android 2.3 firmware.

share|improve this question
4  
This is a fairly subjective question. Asking for advice is generally frowned upon on Stack Exchange sites; we want questions where there could be a single answer. However, I think information on the Pros and Cons of HTC Sense with Froyo vs. stock Gingerbread would be useful to many people. –  Al E. Feb 28 '11 at 14:41

3 Answers 3

up vote 6 down vote accepted

This is pretty much just a matter of preference, to be honest. I don't think you'll really "lose" any functionality on a Desire by going to an AOSP based ROM, either 2.3 or otherwise. You should gain built-in USB and wifi tethering, though, since those are a standard part of Android 2.2+. The real deciding factor will just be if you prefer the Sense UI or another launcher (ADW, LauncherPro, Zeam, etc). You will lose any HTC widgets since they depend on Sense, but there are widgets in the Market which actually mimic the style and functionality of the HTC ones for just that reason. You also lose HTC's proprietary apps, since they generally use the Sense framework in various ways.

Threads pop up on XDA from time to time where people argue over whether Sense is better than other launchers but it almost inevitably just amounts to each group saying "I think X better than Y because I like the way it looks".

share|improve this answer
    
I do not "value" too much the skinning and I'm more interested about features, like ones added by 2.3. Still there is one functionality that I would like to be able to use: HTC said that you get free GPS routing with off-line maps on HTC Desire HD. I am going to be able to use this even if I go for AOSP ROM? –  sorin Feb 28 '11 at 0:16
    
@Sorin: There are several questions here regarding offline maps and navigation, but I don't personally know what HTC's navigation application does. I don't think I even used it on my EVO since it had Google Maps anyway, the latest version of which does (to an extent) support offline usage via cached maps. I don't know of any way to use the HTC app on an AOSP ROM, though. –  eldarerathis Feb 28 '11 at 0:23
    
I switched to the CyanoModGen and I'm really happy with what. –  sorin Mar 3 '11 at 20:36

My answer focuses a bit more on the Sense vs No-Sense (see the bottom part for links about 2.3 vs 2.2).

I currently have a Sense based ROM on my EVO and CyanogenMod on my old Hero. Now there are differences in the devices so that must be taken into account but here is what I have found.

On my Hero, I had a Sense based ROM for a long time and liked it (I kinda prefer Sense). When I tried AOSP ROMs they tended to be faster and give me better battery-life but from time to time would cause my Hero to reboot. When I got tired of this I went back to a Sense based ROM it was slow but never reboot on me. Eventually I got tired of the slowness and went back to CyanogenMod for the Hero. The other thing I liked about CyanogenMod was the Photos app that would grab photos from Picasa's Web Albums. I didn't like that the Sense widgets and Sense apps (like the clock widget and app with all the integrated functionality) were gone and the keyboard was the stock one (personally I prefer the HTC keyboard). Now as eldarerathis already mentioned you can find similar replacements for the widgets and apps but in my attempts nothing I found was perfect - you may find that different.

On my EVO I have only tried a Sense ROM. I have excellent battery-life, all the sense functionality and with the ROM I'm using (Fresh 3.5) there is an app added that will allow you to add the Google apps (clock, photos, etc.) or the AOSP lock screen. I have the wireless and USB tether that eldarerathis mentioned as well and as he already mentioned the merits of Google Maps.

I can't say that I have tried any ROM's for the Desire either Sense or AOSP but here is a link to the CyanogenMod Forum for the Desire if you wanted to see what other people are experiencing with that ROM.

Here are some links that explain some differences between 2.3 and 2.2 breaking them down my feature sets:

http://www.differencebetween.com/difference-between-android-2-2-froyo-and-android-2-3-gingerbread/

http://www.bizzntech.com/2011/02/20/android-gingerbread-2-3-vs-froyo-2-2

share|improve this answer

I have to disagree with eldarerathis. I've never used Sense, but the number of problems people have with it indicate to me that it is inferior on a reliability level. While vanilla Android is not perfect either, I would certainly trust it more.

share|improve this answer
2  
This is also "true" with MotoBLUR and Samsung TouchWiz. The great part of what android is, is open, allowing these companies to customize their product to be more "their own". with that said, from personal experience, "Stock" android is more stable then these modifications of android. While they may have additional features, or enhancements, some of them don't always work that well. They are becoming more stable as time goes on and they fix the issues, but they are very slow to roll them out to the devices. I would take AOSP android over any other manufacture modifications any day. –  Ryan Conrad Mar 2 '11 at 17:48
    
I've definitely heard bad things about MotoBLUR as well, but I think most of the "TouchWiz issues" are really unrelated "Samsung issues". I've never had a problem with TW on a custom ROM, but lots of issues I had with stock ROMs initially appeared to be TW-related. –  Matthew Read Mar 2 '11 at 18:45

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.