Seems that your recovery got broken, Now you'll have to flash another one the same way you did the first one, via Odin, and i recommend you this version,
[CWM_Touch_6.0.4.4_with_Odin][1]
After you flash the recovery, Boot into it, Then select the "GAPPS" version that is compatible with the ROM version you've installed, If you don't have it, Just choose the compatible one from this thread
[GAPPS_ALL_VER][2]
Once you flash GAPPS, you're done. [1]: https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B_1zjuazXSqbd2lCNnFET21fWG8/edit [2]: http://forum.xda-developers.com/android/software/pa-gapps-continuation-t3098071